Coinbase vs Gemini: Complete Comparison 2025

Coinbase and Gemini are the two most trusted US crypto exchanges, both founded by well-known entrepreneurs and fully regulated. They’re more similar than different, but key distinctions exist. Here’s my comparison after years of using both.

Quick Summary

Feature	Coinbase	Gemini
Trading Fees	0.40-0.60%	0.20-0.40%
Cryptocurrencies	200+	100+
Founded	2012	2014
Best For	Beginners, mobile	Security, withdrawals
Rating	4.5/5	4.4/5
Free Withdrawals	No	10/month

Fees Comparison

Trading Fees

Coinbase:

• Simple: 1.49% or fixed
• Advanced Trade: 0.40% maker / 0.60% taker

Gemini:

• Simple: 1.49% or fixed
• ActiveTrader: 0.20% maker / 0.40% taker

For a $10,000 trade:

• Coinbase Advanced: $60.00
• Gemini ActiveTrader: $40.00

Winner: Gemini - Lower trading fees on ActiveTrader.

Withdrawals

Coinbase: Network fees on all crypto withdrawals Gemini: 10 FREE withdrawals per month

Winner: Gemini - Free withdrawals are a unique advantage.

Security Comparison

Both exchanges have impeccable security:

Coinbase:

• Never hacked since 2012
• FDIC insurance on USD
• Publicly traded (NASDAQ)
• 98% cold storage

Gemini:

• Never hacked since 2014
• SOC 2 Type II certified
• NY Trust company
• 95% cold storage
• Winklevoss founders

Winner: Tie - Both are excellent for security-conscious users.

Cryptocurrency Selection

Coinbase: 200+ cryptocurrencies Gemini: 100+ cryptocurrencies

Winner: Coinbase - Double the selection.

User Experience

Coinbase:

• Industry-best mobile app (4.8 stars)
• Clean, intuitive interface
• Learn & Earn program
• Easier for beginners

Gemini:

• Good mobile app (4.7 stars)
• Professional interface
• Nifty Gateway (NFTs)
• More serious feel

Winner: Coinbase - Slightly better user experience.

Unique Features

Coinbase:

• Learn & Earn (free crypto)
• Coinbase Card (4% cashback)
• Recurring buys
• NFT marketplace (limited)

Gemini:

• 10 free withdrawals/month
• Gemini Credit Card (3% rewards)
• Nifty Gateway (NFT platform)
• Gemini Custody (institutional)

Winner: Tie - Different strengths.

My Personal Setup

Coinbase (60%):

• Day-to-day trading
• DCA automation
• Mobile purchases
• Crypto card spending

Gemini (40%):

• Long-term storage (free withdrawals to cold storage)
• Larger purchases
• Institutional-level security

Who Should Choose Which?

Choose Coinbase If:

• You want the easiest experience
• You prefer a better mobile app
• You want more cryptocurrencies
• You like Learn & Earn programs
• You’re a complete beginner

Choose Gemini If:

• You withdraw to cold storage often (free!)
• You want slightly lower fees
• You value Winklevoss reputation
• You need institutional custody
• You’re security-obsessed

Final Verdict

Overall Winner: Coinbase - Better mobile experience and more coins.

For Withdrawals: Gemini - 10 free per month is valuable.

These are both excellent US exchanges. Many users, myself included, use both. Coinbase for convenience and selection, Gemini for free withdrawals to hardware wallets.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is cheaper, Coinbase or Gemini?

Gemini ActiveTrader (0.20-0.40%) is cheaper than Coinbase Advanced (0.40-0.60%).

Which is safer?

Both are equally safe with perfect security records and strong insurance.

Which has more cryptocurrencies?

Coinbase offers 200+ vs Gemini’s 100+.

Does Gemini really offer free withdrawals?

Yes, 10 free crypto withdrawals per month, which is unique among major exchanges.

Can I use both?

Yes, many users use Coinbase for trading and Gemini for free withdrawals to cold storage.

---

Last updated: January 2025. I actively use both Coinbase and Gemini. This comparison reflects genuine experience. Affiliate links may provide compensation at no extra cost to you.